The Edgar Awards

In January of this year the Mystery Writers of America announced their 2025 Edgar Allan Poe Award nominations.  It's a prestigious award dating back to the 1940's and each year the Edgars honor "the best in mystery fiction, nonfiction and television"  Here are this year's Edgar nominations for best mystery/crime novel published in 2024:

The Tainted Cup by Robert Jackson Bennett 

Rough Trade by Katrina Carrasco 

Things Don’t Break on Their Own by Sarah Easter Collins 

My Favorite Scar by Nicolás Ferraro 

The God of the Woods by Liz Moore 

Listen for the Lie by Amy Tintera

The In Crowd by Charlotte Vassell 

I have read and posted my thoughts about Listen For The Lie by Amy Tintera which I reallly enjoyed and recommend.  Haven't read the others but I am on hold for The God of The Woods by Liz Moore with 9 weeks still left to go. 

The Edgars tend to focus on noir and hard boiled mystery/crime novels.  And so I got curious and went back to the first Edgar award winners from the 1940's and early 50's.  Many of those books are out of print but with kindle unlimited and the Libby reading service I have been able to check out a few and right now I am listening on audio to A Kiss Before Dying by Ira Levin (1954 Edgar for Best First Novel) which so far is a real page turning experience.  The 2025 Edgar Award winners will be announced in May.

The Lion, The Witch And The Wardrobe by C. S. Lewis

For the classic's challenge category, choose a children's classic, hosted by Ann at Search For Wonder I chose The Lion, The Witch And The Wardrobe (1950) by C. S. Lewis.  It's the second book in Lewis's acclaimed Narnia series.  But even if you haven't read the other books in the series, and I haven't, The Lion, The Witch And The Wardrobe can be read as a stand-alone and it's worth your time.

Peter, Susan, Edmund and Lucy are siblings who when the novel begins are living in the English countryside at the home of a kindly professor.  The year is 1940 and the children were sent to the countryside from London due to the blitz.  The professor's home is huge with many rooms and secret compartments.  And since their parents are not with them, possibly still in London, the children are on their own and begin exploring the house.  It is Lucy who first discovers the wardrobe cabinet: 

"This must be a simply enormous wardrobe!" thought Lucy, going still further in and pushing the soft folds of the coats aside to make room for her. Then she noticed that there was something crunching under her feet. "I wonder is that more moth-balls?" she thought, stooping down to feel it with her hands. But instead of feeling the hard, smooth wood of the floor of the wardrobe, she felt something soft and powdery and extremely cold ... And then she saw that there was a light ahead of her; not a few inches away where the back of the wardrobe ought to have been .. A moment later she found that she was standing in the middle of a wood at night-time with snow under her feet and snowflakes falling through the air" 

Lucy finds herself in the world of Narnia which is run by the evil White Witch.  In Narnia it is always winter but there is no Christmas.  The witch who refers to herself as the Queen of Narnia forbids it.  And if the animals, birds, fauns and other creatures who live in Narnia disobey the Queen she will turn them into stone.  

Lucy upon arriving in Narnia is greeted by a faun named Mr. Tumnus.  He is friendly and invites Lucy to his cave for tea and cake.  Lucy is the first human Mr.Tumnus has ever seen.  Humans are referred to by the people of Narnia as sons of Adam and daughters of Eve.  The Queen is terrified of humans because there is a prophecy that when four humans, two sons of Adam and two daughters of Eve, sit on the four thrones of Cair Paravel the reign of the White Witch will be over and a great and good Lion named Aslan will rule Narnia.

Mr. Tumnus tells Lucy all this and he also confesses that the White Witch has sent him to Lucy so that he can bring her to the witch's castle.  But he doesn't have the heart to do it and helps Lucy escape.  When Lucy returns home she tells Peter, Edmund and Susan about Narnia.  They don't believe her.  

But in a day or two all four children go through the wardrobe together and arrive in Narnia.  They learn that Mr Tumnus has been arrested for treason for disobeying the White Witch by helping Lucy escape.  Lucy, Peter and Susan are scared but they are also brave and they feel they must rescue Mr. Tumnus.  

Edmund in comparison is not so noble.  He went through the wardrobe door once before and he met the White Witch and fell under her spell.  He is particularly interested in the delicious Turkish Delight candy the witch dispenses and her promise that if Edmund does what she asks he will be made a Prince of Narnia.  I will leave the story there.  

The Lion The Witch And The Wardrobe can be read as a Christian allegory, a children's fantasy novel or just as a good story.  Lucy, Peter, Edmund and Susan are well drawn and  each is very much their own person.  Lucy is kind hearted, inquisitive and she takes risks.  Peter being the eldest feels responsible for the younger children.  Edmund resents Peter's authority.  Susan is quiet and gentle but brave when it matters.

I have read my share of children's classics in the past few years.  And though a few have been a let down, the majority: Little House In The Big Woods, Ramona The Pest, Anne of Green Gables and now The Lion, The Witch And The Wardrobe are first rate and these books can be enjoyed at any age. 

Desperate Times: Stories From The Great Depression by Cornell Woolrich

The Great Depression of the 1930's is an era that has always interested me.  I am also a fan of the writer Cornell Woolrich (1903 - 1968).  And so a collection of Woolrich's short stories written during and about the Great Depression, sign me up!  

There are 8 stories in Desperate Times and 7 of the stories center around characters who are down on their luck.  If times were different these characters would never have resorted to murder, faking their own death, fraud, identity theft etc.  But the bad economy as they see it has left them no choice.  

One of the stories for example, Borrowed Crime, involves  a father who needs money to save his son who is dying of TB.  The father reads the newspaper and learns that the police are offering $1,000 leading to the arrest of a killer.  The father decides he will confess to the murder he didn't committ and collect the reward money.  Needless to say it doesn't go well.

And that's a theme throughout these seven stories.  Each of these characters decides to do something illegal thinking it will get them out of the desperate situation they find themselves in only to discover after they have crossed the line that they are in much worse shape now and can't go back.  

The 8th story, Even God Felt The Depression, was written by Cornell Woolrich near the end of his life.  It's his autobiographical look back on what it was like in NYC in the 1930's  trying to make it as a writer:  

"The nights were even more excruciating. To me those long lines of lights that flamed along the Avenues as far as the eye could see were never garish (as they probably were) but glamorous, seeming to hold out a promise of wonderment and magic, and I wanted to be out where they were. Everyone else was, in droves ... and there I sat, in a solitary room, locked in the lonely pool of light cast by a desk lamp. But I wouldn’t leave the desk. I almost had to grab it with both hands and hang onto it for dear life, almost had to hook my ankles around its legs to stay on the chair, but I wouldn’t leave it, no I wouldn’t leave it" 

Woolrich's hard work and perseverance paid off.  He is considered today to be one of the great crime novelists of the mid-twentieth century.  I would say though that if you are new to Woolrich, Desperate Times is not the best place to begin.  I enjoyed these stories and they gave me a sense of the kind of novels Woolrich would become famous for in the 1940's.  But they are not on the same level as The Bride Wore Black, Deadline At Dawn, Walz Into Darkness etc all written in the 1940's when Woolrich really hit his stride.  

I have read and recommend The Bride Wore Black and I will definitely be checking out Deadline At Dawn and Walz Into Darkness in the not too distant future.  

The Shining by Stephen King

The Shining (1977) is my first Stephen King novel which I chose because it's one of his most popular and critically acclaimed books.  It's a horror novel but also a tremendously interesting family drama centering around three characters: Jack Torrance, his wife Wendy and their five year old son Danny who has psychic abilities.

Jack is a writer and a recovering alcoholic.  He hasn't had a drink in two years since the night when in a drunken rage he accidentally broke his son Danny's arm.  Wendy almost left Jack after that but he vowed to stop drinking and he hasn't had a drink since.  

Jack continues to feel guilt about what he did to Danny.  These days he is a good father and Danny loves him.  But even sober Jack's temper can be a problem.  It's why he lost his last job as a teacher at a prep school. And when The Shining begins Jack has a new job as a caretaker for the winter at the Overlook Hotel located high up in the Colorado Rockies. The Overlook closes down during the winter months and so Jack, Wendy and Danny will be the hotel's only residents.  

It's not an ideal situation but Jack and his family need the money. Jack is also hoping to use the time at the Overlook to finish writing his play.  Wendy and Danny are not thrilled about accompanying Jack to this isolated environment but they want to be supportive. However it soon becomes clear that moving into the Overlook was a very bad idea.

Stephen King has done a marvelous job creating the characters of Jack, Wendy and Danny.  And there is also Dick Halloran who works at the Overlook. Like Danny, Dick Hallorann is psychic, the shining he calls it.  He is going home for the winter along with all of the other guests and employees.  But Hallorann tells Danny that if he needs him to reach out through his psychic powers and he will come back to the Overlook.

I really liked Dick Hallorann. Wendy and Danny are also very well drawn. I would say though that the most fascinating character is Jack Torrance. You can't say he is likeable exactly but he has good in him.  But Jack's emotions can run from remorse to self pity to rage and in a haunted hotel with evil forces at work it's a powder keg situation.

The Shining is a horror novel and things can get pretty intense, particularly as you near the end.  But it is also a wonderfully written book, gripping, with great characterization.  I am glad I chose The Shining for my first Stephen King novel.  And there is a sequel, Doctor Sleep, published in 2013.

Knife: Meditations After An Attempted Murder by Salman Rushdie

"I remembered the question I had asked myself after the attack: Could our happiness survive such a blow? Standing there, on the stage of the Chautauqua amphitheater, I knew the answer. Yes, we had reconstructed our happiness, even if imperfectly. Even on this blue-sky day, I knew it was not the cloudless thing we had known before. It was a wounded happiness, and there was, and perhaps always would be, a shadow in the corner of it. But it was a strong happiness nevertheless, and as we embraced, I knew it would be enough" - Salman Rushdie, Knife

On August 12, 2022 Salman Rushdie was giving a talk at an outdoor event in upstate New York when a deranged young man rushed on stage and stabbed Rushdie 15 times almost killing him.  It was such a terrible crime. Since 1989 when Iran issued the fatwa Rushdie has lived a life that none of us can imagine.  But I had thought it was over with and that Rushdie would be able to live in peace.  And then came that day.  

I was hesitant to read Knife but I shouldn't have been.  Rushdie writes about the attack and his painful recovery and that can be difficult to read.  The attack blinded him in one eye and there were other serious injuries.  But the book is also about Rushdie's recovery, his inner strength and the support of his family.  His wife Eliza who has been with him every step of the way.  His sister, his two sons who rushed to New York to be by his side. Rushdie's friends and the hospital staff also helped him greatly.

Salman Rushdie is an excellent writer.  Knife is thoughtful and humorous at times.  He writes about many things in his memoir, his childhood, his life as a writer, his friendships, religion, politics, his thoughts on the importance of privacy.  Rushdie has led a full life.  The attack is not something he will forget but he is amazingly resilient and  continues to have good people with him.  And so a book I was afraid to read turned out to be quite inspiring.

Three Years In A Walmart Parking Lot by Sharon Waters

Sharon Waters was 69 years of age and could no longer afford the upkeep of the house she had been living in with her partner of 15 years.  Their relationship had ended and so Sharon went looking for an apartment but most apartments would not take her two dogs Crickett and Magic and her cat Milo.  Sharon's children were busy with their own lives and she didn't want to be a burden.  

And so Sharon sold her home, bought an RV and took off with her pets, traveling south, sometimes staying a few days with friends but mostly exploring the small towns and spending her nights in the RV with Cricket, Magic and Milo in Walmart Super Center parking lots.  It was a life changing experience.  Proof that even when we get older there are still adventures out there if we can find the courage.

A good deal of Three Years In A Walmart Parking Lot (2019) is taken up with the maintenance of Sharon's RV which is not easy.  But Sharon deserves so much credit for teaching herself what she needed to know.  The part of the book that spoke to me the most was what Sharon learned about herself.  Here are a few passages I noted:

"I liked the sense of isolation and invisibility, hiding in plain sight, removed from anything threatening. There were no stern looks of disapproval, no mail with bad news or phone calls I didn’t want to take. I was inconspicuous, unseen, untraceable. I had my cell phone but rarely answered it". 

"I enjoyed starting the day with hot coffee"

"Anything I’m not looking forward to gets done first—I just do it, with my mind on the completion, not the drudgery of the task"

Sharon Waters after three years moved into an apartment that would take her pets.  She makes a good case that RV living is not sustainable long term because as the years go by the RV breaks down, needs repairs, gas is expensive and places that will let you park for the night are dwindling.  But Sharon does not regret her three years on the road and I too am glad she took the journey and chose to share what she learned.

Listen For The Lie by Amy Tintera

When Listen For The Lie (2024) by Amy Tintera begins Lucy Chase is living in Los Angeles working for a financial corporation and keeping a low profile.  Lucy's coworkers see her as standoffish but she is harboring a dark secret. 

Five years prior when Lucy was living in her hometown of Plumpton, Texas she went to a wedding reception with her best friend Savannah (Savvy) Harper.  At some point the two young women left the reception and Savvy was later found bludgeoned to death in a wooded area.  Lucy was seen shortly after Savvy's murder walking down a dirt road dazed and covered in Savvy's blood.

Lucy was questioned by the police at the time but she had no memory of what happened that night and still doesn't.  The police decided not to prosecute because there was not enough evidence. But the town of Plumpton never believed that Lucy had no memory of what happened.  They believed she killed Savvy.

Lucy leaves Plumpton for Los Angeles hoping for a new start.  But now, five years later, a popular true crime podcaster has decided to reopen the Savannah Harper murder case.  Lucy's employers in LA find out who she is and she is fired.

And to make it worse Lucy's grandmother calls her up hoping that Lucy can return to Plumpton for her 80th birthday.  It's the last thing Lucy wants to do but her grandmother is the only person in Plumpton who believes Lucy. And so she decides to return to Plumpton only to find the podcaster Ben Owen there as well interviewing the locals and wanting an interview with Lucy most of all.  

Listen For the Lie is narrated by Lucy Chase in a cynical dark humor sort of way but it's a shield because Lucy remains devastated by what happened to her best friend.  She genuinely can't remember that night.  And she begins to trust Ben because he is committed to solving cases and has had success in the past.  Lucy is at a point where she has to know what happened to Savvy, wherever that may lead.

I thought Listen For The Lie was top notch as a thriller and I am not alone.  30,000 reviews on Amazon with 88% of them 4 and 5 stars.  Very good reviews too from the critics.  The thriller genre can be a hit or a miss.  But here it's definitely a hit.  I was never bored, everything made sense to me and I enjoy novels with true crime podcasting plots.  4 stars for me.