Listen For The Lie by Amy Tintera

When Listen For The Lie (2024) by Amy Tintera begins Lucy Chase is living in Los Angeles working for a financial corporation and keeping a low profile.  Lucy's coworkers see her as standoffish but she is harboring a dark secret. 

Five years prior when Lucy was living in her hometown of Plumpton, Texas she went to a wedding reception with her best friend Savannah (Savvy) Harper.  At some point the two young women left the reception and Savvy was later found bludgeoned to death in a wooded area.  Lucy was seen shortly after Savvy's murder walking down a dirt road dazed and covered in Savvy's blood.

Lucy was questioned by the police at the time but she had no memory of what happened that night and still doesn't.  The police decided not to prosecute because there was not enough evidence. But the town of Plumpton never believed that Lucy had no memory of what happened.  They believed she killed Savvy.

Lucy leaves Plumpton for Los Angeles hoping for a new start.  But now, five years later, a popular true crime podcaster has decided to reopen the Savannah Harper murder case.  Lucy's employers in LA find out who she is and she is fired.

And to make it worse Lucy's grandmother calls her up hoping that Lucy can return to Plumpton for her 80th birthday.  It's the last thing Lucy wants to do but her grandmother is the only person in Plumpton who believes Lucy. And so she decides to return to Plumpton only to find the podcaster Ben Owen there as well interviewing the locals and wanting an interview with Lucy most of all.  

Listen For the Lie is narrated by Lucy Chase in a cynical dark humor sort of way but it's a shield because Lucy remains devastated by what happened to her best friend.  She genuinely can't remember that night.  And she begins to trust Ben because he is committed to solving cases and has had success in the past.  Lucy is at a point where she has to know what happened to Savvy, wherever that may lead.

I thought Listen For The Lie was top notch as a thriller and I am not alone.  30,000 reviews on Amazon with 88% of them 4 and 5 stars.  Very good reviews too from the critics.  The thriller genre can be a hit or a miss.  But here it's definitely a hit.  I was never bored, everything made sense to me and I enjoy novels with true crime podcasting plots.  4 stars for me.

The Picture of Dorian Gray by Oscar Wilde

"The story revolves around a portrait of Dorian Gray painted by Basil Hallward, a friend of Dorian's and an artist infatuated with Dorian's beauty. Through Basil, Dorian meets Lord Henry Wotton and is soon enthralled by the aristocrat's hedonistic worldview: beauty and sensual fulfillment are the only things worth pursuing. Newly understanding that his beauty will fade, Dorian desires to sell his soul to ensure that the picture, rather than he, will age and fade. The wish is granted, and Dorian pursues a libertine life of varied amoral experiences while staying young and beautiful; all the while, his portrait ages and visually records every one of Dorian's sins". - Amazon blurb

The Picture of Dorian Gray (1891) by Oscar Wilde is book two for my classics challenge, choose a gothic classic, hosted by Ann at Search For Wonder.  I thought I would be reading Dragonwyck by Anya Seton but I decided to go with The Picture of Dorian Gray instead.

And having read Lady Windermere's Fan by Oscar Wilde a few years ago I knew what a talented and witty writer he was but I was taken aback by the brilliance of The Picture of Dorian Gray.  It's one of those classics where you know why it's a classic.  Here for example is the cynical Lord Henry Wotton who upon first meeting young Dorian at the unveiling of his portrait tells him: 

"Because to influence a person is to give him one's own soul. He does not think his natural thoughts, or burn with his natural passions. His virtues are not real to him. His sins, if there are such things as sins, are borrowed. He becomes an echo of some one else's music, an actor of a part that has not been written for him. The aim of life is self-development. To realize one's nature perfectly—that is what each of us is here for. People are afraid of themselves, nowadays ... Courage has gone out of our race. Perhaps we never really had it. The terror of society, which is the basis of morals, the terror of God, which is the secret of religion—these are the two things that govern us" 

The irony is that Lord Henry who warns Dorian not to be influenced by others makes sure at their first meeting to influence him in a very dangerous way:

"The moment I met you I saw that you were quite unconscious of what you really are, of what you really might be. There was so much in you that charmed me that I felt I must tell you something about yourself. I thought how tragic it would be if you were wasted. For there is such a little time that your youth will last—such a little time"

And it's that advise that puts fear into Dorian about losing his beauty and youth, a fear that was not there before Lord Henry came into his life.  Dorian now terrified of growing old says a prayer to remain always young.  He is granted his wish.  And Dorian spurred on by Lord Henry's worldview begins to lead a life of debauchery. He remains young and beautiful as the years go by but his portrait, locked away in the attic, becomes more and more hideous. 

Lord Henry is a scoundrel but I didn't finish the book feeling empathy for Dorian Gray either.  Lord Henry certainly influenced Dorian but Basil Hallward the painter of Dorian's portrait was a true friend to Dorian and he warned him about Lord Henry but Dorian would not listen.

The Picture of Dorian Gray is a great novel and I do recommend it.  But one thing I will say is that in quite a number of 19th century classics you will run into prejudice and unfortunately it's here in Dorian Gray as well.  It's a shame because this book is brilliant but I am glad we live in somewhat more enlightened times.

The Sky Unwashed by Irene Zabytko

I was scrolling through Amazon a few months ago and discovered The Sky Unwashed (2000) by Irene Zabytko.  I had never heard of the author but the plot and the atmospheric cover drew me in and I knew this was a novel that I would be reading.

The Sky Unwashed is set in 1986 in the rural Ukranian village of Starylis.  For generations the residents of Starylis made their living through farming.  The older residents keep the traditions and customs.  In comparison many of the younger people scoff at the traditions of their parents and grandparents.  They want a  more modern life and to be able to afford nice clothes and new appliances.

Life in Starylis is not that different from other rural villages across Ukraine with one historically tragic exception.  Starylis is just down the road from the nuclear power plant at Chernobyl where many of the residents of Starylis report to work. 

The Sky Unwashed begins at a wedding celebration which everyone in the village is attending.  Marusia Petrenko bakes her famous wedding bread for the occasion and is very pleased at the compliments she is getting.  Marusia who is in her 70's is a sweet person and at the reception there is drinking and dancing.  And then Marusia's son Yurko and some of the other men at the party leave to work their nightshift jobs at the Chernobyl plant and as the Amazon blurb tells us:

"In the morning, the air has a strange metallic taste. The cat is oddly listless. The priest doesn't show up for services. Yurko doesn't come home from work. Nobody know what's happened (and they won't for many days), but things have changed for the Petrenkos-forever"

The majority of The Sky Unwashed takes place a year later when Marusia decides after all she has been through to move back to her home in Starylis.  It's a sealed off area, closed to the public.  But Marusia decides that if she is going to die anywhere it will be in her home.  And this is based on a true story of grandmothers ("The Babushkas of Chernobyl") who returned to their homes, tried to plant new gardens and would not listen to the authorities when ordered to leave.

The Sky Unwashed is moving, funny at times and sad.  But despite the sadness I am glad I read this novel.  Irene Zabytko has a nice writing style and Marusia is an inspiring character.

The Bone Garden by Tess Gerritsen

The Bone Garden (2007) by Tess Gerritsen is a historical dual timeline mystery.  And the novel begins in present day Weston, MA when we are introduced to Julia Hamill.  Julia is recently divorced and somewhat lost as to how to proceed with her life.  She has bought an old home that she is repairing and while trying to plant a garden she uncovers the skeletal remains of a woman buried on her property a very long time ago.  The woman was murdered but her remains date back to the early 19th century and so the police close the case.  But Julia maybe as a way to escape from her current anxieties decides to investigate. 

We then go back to Weston, MA 1830 (where most of the book will take place) and we meet Norris Marshall a medical student.  Norris is conscientious and very smart.  He attends Boston Medical College.  But to be able to afford medical school like many other young men of that time he works as a "resurectionist", someone who steals dead bodies which are sold on a black market to medical schools.

And then a nurse is found brutally murdered and within a few days another nurse and then a doctor is murdered in the same gruesome way.   The newspapers are calling the killer The West End Reaper and before long Norris is the prime suspect.   But Norris is innocent and a young seamstress Rose Connolly knows this because she was there the night both she and Norris caught a shadowy glimpse of the killer fleeing the scene of the crime.  Norris and Rose must work together to find out who the killer is because both of their lives are at stake.  

The Bone Garden also includes a real life historical figure, Oliver Wendall Holmes, Sr. who would later go on to great acclaim after discovering a medical breakthrough that would save many lives.  He is also the father of Oliver Wendall Holmes Jr who would later become a Supreme Court Justice.  

But mainly this novel is about the fictional Norris Marshall and Rose Connolly.  They meet under less than ideal circumstances but Gerritsen creates a real chemistry between Norris and Rose.  And though the book is long, 500 pages, I read it in 4 days and enjoyed it a great deal.  One thing to keep in mind the book is graphic in describing autopsies. But if you don't mind some blood and guts I heartily recommend The Bone Garden.

Homegoing by Yaa Gyasi

"There’s a castle on the coast in Fanteland called the Cape Coast Castle. That is where they used to keep the slaves before they sent them away, to Aburokyire: America, Jamaica. Asante traders would bring in their captives. Fante, Ewe, or Ga middlemen would hold them, then sell them to the British or the Dutch or whoever was paying the most at the time. Everyone was responsible. We all were…we all are.” - Yaa Gyasi, Homegoing.

Homegoing by the Ghanaian-American writer Yaa Gyasi begins in 18th century Ghana with two half-sisters, Effia and Esi, who live in different villages.  The sisters are told when they are young that they have a sibling but they never meet each other.

Effia remains in Ghana and marries a British man, James Collins, who is the Governor of Cape Coast Castle.  It will be a happy life for Effia although she blocks out the fact that her husband makes his money in the slave trade.  

And that brings us to Esi who, in comparison to Effia's life, is living a nightmare.  Esi along with others from her village is kidnapped, sold into slavery and put on a ship headed for America.   

The novel proceeds and we learn about the different paths Effia and Esi's lives take.  We also learn about the lives of their descendents.  We watch Effia's children, grandchildren, great grandchildren navigate the changes happening in Ghana.  And we follow Esi's descendents in America through the Civil War, the Great Migration, the Jazz Age and on up to the present.  

In 2016 Homegoing won The National Book Critics Circle Award and I can see why.   I was invested in the lives of Effia and Esi's descendents all the way through this novel.  Yaa Gyasi is an excellent writer and Homegoing is one of the best books I will read this year.

Walden: Or, Life In The Woods by Henry David Thoreau

"I rejoice that there are owls. Let them do the idiotic and maniacal hooting for men. It is a sound admirably suited to swamps and twilight woods which no day illustrates, suggesting a vast and undeveloped nature which men have not recognized. They represent the stark twilight and unsatisfied thoughts which all have. All day the sun has shone ... but now a more dismal and fitting day dawns, and a different race of creatures awakes to express the meaning of Nature there." -  Henry David Thoreau

This year I am taking a classics challenge created by Anne at In Search of Wonder.  Anne's prompt for January was to read a book from our TBR list and so I decided to read Walden; Or Life In The Woods (1854) by Henry David Thoreau.  

Currently I am half way through Walden.  It's not a book you can breeze rhrough and so I am taking it slow so I can reflect on what Henry David Thoreau has to say about nature, solitude, civilization and the meaning of life: 

These days Henry David Thoreau is more popular and widely known than he ever was during his lifetime.  And today with people building their tiny houses or getting into their RV and heading west the philosophy behind Walden lives on.  And with the weather getting better maybe the best way to read Thoreau is outdoors experiencing the natural world that he loved and wrote about so powerfully.

Vera Wong's Unsolicited Advice For Muderers by Jesse O. Sutanto

"No one can say that Vera is boastful. No, Vera is many things, but boastful is not one of them. And yet, even she has to admit that her first day of investigating has exceeded all expectations ... Truly, even the police would be forced to admit that she’s very nearly solved their case for them. It’s not even time for her afternoon tea yet, and already she has three whole suspects. Superb work, Vera, simply marvelous, she tells herself, as she brews a pot of jujubes and goji berries tea. When the tea is done, Vera settles on her chair with a satisfied sigh and takes out her notebook." - Jesse O. Sutanto

Thank you Tracy at Bitter Tea and Mystery for introducing me to Vera Wong's Unsolicited Advice for Murderers (2023) by Jesse O. Sutanto.  This novel is funny, touching and Vera Wong is such a great character and how thrilled am I that there is now a second book in this really fine new mystery series.  

The setting is present day San Francisco and Vera is a 60 year old widow who owns a tea shop which she has named "Vera Wang’s World-Famous Teahouse" so that she can attract more business.  Her son Tilly is exasperated by this name since if the famous  designer were to find out about this his mother could be sued.  But then again Vera's tea shop, which has seen better days, is in no danger of being discovered until one day Vera who lives above her shop comes downstairs and discovers a dead body.  

Most people would be horrified.  But Vera who lives by herself and has a son who is too busy to visit is lonely.  And so when Vera finds the dead man, Marshall Chen, on the floor of her tea house its exciting and a chance to be useful.  Vera calls the police and prepares a special tea for the occasion.  But the two officers decline the tea and are not amused when they discover that Vera has taken a sharpie and drawn an outline around the dead body as the investigators do on the CSI programs she watches.  

The officers order Vera to stop interfering.  But that's not happening and Vera decides to place an ad in the newspaper in an effort to attract suspects.  Aquaintances of Marshall Chen begin arriving at the tea shop to talk with Vera while sipping the teas she has prepared. 

 

The chapters alternate between Vera's perspective and those of her customer/suspects.  There is Marshall's wife Julia, his twin brother Oliver and Riki and Suna who also have a connection to the deceased. All four have been unnerved by Marshall's death not because they are grieving.  Marshall was a bad guy and each of the suspects has motive.

But it's Vera who makes this book special.  She is such an endearing character who despite her loneliness faces life with determination.  She goes for a walk every morning and then opens her tea shop despite the fact that it is attracting no business.  But even  Vera as the novel begins is wondering what's the point of it all until an exciting purpose enters her life, solving Marshall Chen's murder.

Vera Wong's Unsolicited Advice for Murderers is a real treat.  And I hope this novel is the start of a very long mystery series.