Monday, May 13, 2024

The Midwife's Apprentice by Karen Cushman

The Midwife's Apprentice (1991) by Karen Cushman is the third Newbery Award winning novel that I have read for the Historical Fiction Reading Challenge hosted by Marg at The Intrepid Reader and Baker.  I have been choosing these Newbery books because they are well written and let's face it relatively short.  But I need to move on soon to adult medieval historical fiction and I plan to do so with my next choice.

But for now it's The Midwife's Apprentice and once again this novel, though written for kids, doesn't sugar coat life in the middle ages, particularly for the poor.  The young heroine of this novel who at the beginning is called Beetle by the sneering villagers has no family or place to live.  She doesn't remember her mother or her father: 

"Someone, she assumed, must have borne her and cared for her lest she toddle into the pond and changed her diapers when they reeked, but as long as she could remember, she had lived on her own by what means she could—stealing an onion here or helping with the harvest there in exchange for a night on the stable floor. She took what she could from a village and moved on before the villagers, with their rakes and sticks, drove her away. Snug cottages and warm bread and mothers who hugged their babes were beyond her imagining, but dearly would she have loved to eat a turnip without the mud of the field still on it or sleep in a barn fragrant with new hay"

Beetle is about 12 or 13 when the book begins and she sleeps wherever she can find shelter, scavenges for food.  It's a dangerous existance and Beetle's situation was probably the life most orphan kids lived throughout much of history.  But then Beetle's luck changes when she meets a midwife, Jane Sharp, who decides to take her in as an apprentice.  But the midwife is not a motherly figure.  Jane is mean and constantly ridicules Beetle.  But working for the midwife gives Beetle food and a place to stay and then one day at the county fair Beetle has a wonderful time and it's a turning point in her life:

"What a day! She had been winked at, complimented, given a gift, and now mistaken for the mysterious Alyce who could read. Did she then look like someone who could read? She leaned over and watched her face in the water again. 'This face,' she said, 'could belong to someone who can read. And has curls ... And this is me, Beetle.' She stopped. Beetle was no name for a person, no name for someone who looked like she could read. Frowning, she thought a minute, and then her face shone as though a torch were fired inside her 'Alyce,' she breathed. Alyce sounded clean and friendly and smart. You could love some- one named Alyce. She looked back at the face in the water. 'This then is me, Alyce.' It was right". 

The newly named Alyce goes on from there and despite her hard beginnings she has a good heart.  She rescues a cat from a group of bullies and the cat becomes her loyal companion.  Alyce also finds a home for a six year old orphan boy named Edward.  And she begins a friendship with a young boy named Will who is indebted to Alyce for saving his life.

I liked the book well enough.  It's well written but of the three Newbery winners I have read this year my favorite continues to be Good Masters! Sweet Ladies! by Laura Amy Schlitz.

14 comments:

  1. I haven't read this one. Sometimes award-winning books end up being a bit disappointing imo.

    ReplyDelete
  2. That's very true Lark. Not every award winner or classic is worthy of its status imo. And then there are other books that never got the critical praise they deserved.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It sounded like a book with huge potential, what a shame it didn't quite live up to its promise or success with the Newbery awards. But that's the way it seems to go sometimes.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I felt the book was okay but maybe the problem is that I have read 3 Newberry novels set in the Middle Ages almost back to back. It's time to move on to Medieval Historical fiction for adults. I know this year I must try to squeeze in The Name of the Rose by Umberto Eco.

      Delete
    2. Oooh, I'll be very interested in how you get on with The Name of the Rose if you get to it. The film was so good. I have Foucault 's Pendulum on my tbr shelf and keep picking it up, looking at it, and then putting it back again. It's quite intimidating.

      Delete
    3. I must try to get to The Name of The Rose because it's one of the top medieval historical novels out there. I will look into Pendulum and I have Cloud Cuckoo Land on my TBR

      Delete
  4. That sounds like an interesting story and probably realistic, I would guess. I am getting more interested in medieval times than I used to be.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's an interesting period. The historians say the medieval era covers 500 to 1500 AD which unfortunately leaves out Henry V III and his 6 wives since their story comes later in the 1500's but I may squeeze in a novel or two about them anyway.

      Delete
    2. The series set in medieval times that I have read a few books from recently is the Chronicles of Brother Cadfael by Ellis Peters.

      Delete
  5. These kids had it tough in the Middle Ages but luckily the ending seems to perk up for Beetle. I'm enjoying your reviews of the Newberry winners.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Susan and It does end well for Beetle. I would imagine that's true for most of the Newbery books certainly the one's I've read. However tough things may be for the protagonists of these books it ends up in a good place with the hero or heroine becoming stronger.

      Delete
  6. I thought I read this one, but it's not showing up on my blog or GoodReads, so maybe I just meant to! I love the premise and you can't go wrong with Newberry Winners. I may have to sneak this one into my summer reading. I love reading medieval literature--one of my absolute favorite time periods. I'll be eager to see what you chose to read.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks and I must read The Name of the Rose before the year is through, a classic novel of Medieval historical fiction

      Delete
  7. Thanks for sharing your review with the Historical Fiction Reading Challenge

    ReplyDelete