Stored in my kindle and around my apartment are loads of unread books and this year I vow to change that. So, first up from my backlist pile is Black Narcissus by Rumer Godden published 1939. I discovered this novel and author through a website I subscribe to, Early Bird Books. The plot of Black Narcissus which centers around a group of nuns living in an isolated corner of the world and the challenges they face sounded interesting. I knew that an acclaimed movie had been made of this book. Would the novel also be worthwhile?
And so when Black Narcissus begins it's the early 20th century. A small group of Anglican sisters has been sent by their religious order, the Servants of Mary, to a remote region in he Himilayas to start a girl's school and a medical clinic. The nuns have been invited to do so by General Toda Rai who owns most of the land in the area including the Palace at Mopu where the sisters will house their school and medical clinic.
General Rai wants to bring progress and education to the local people. He is also embarrassed by the Palace at Mopu where his father when he was alive kept his wife and concubines. By inviting the nuns into the palace, which they rename the convent of St Faith, the General hopes to erase the memories of what went on there. But as the book progresses it becomes clear that the divide between the nuns and the local Hindu population is not going to be bridged. The local people have been living their way of life for thousands of years and are happy to continue doing so. Instead it will be the nuns who are shaken by their life in the Himilayas: the beauty and sensuality of the region, the people, the culture, the hard work building the school and the isolation begin to affect the sisters profoundly, testing their faith.
Sister Ruth for starters is unbalanced and should never have been sent on this journey. Sister Honey loves the children she cares for but gets too involved which leads to trouble. Sister Philippa becomes obsessed with creating a beautiful and expensive garden, neglecting her other duties and then there is Sister Clodagh the young Sister Superior. Mother Dorothea before sending Sister Coldaugh to the Himilayas expresses her doubts to a colleague about the young nun:
She has always felt herself just a little better than anyone else. What makes it so hard to deal with, is the fact that she undoubtedly is. She has great gifts and one can't deny it. But one day I think she'll learn to know herself. I have always found it wiser to let God teach his own lessons in his own time".
Sister Clodagh is the central character in this novel and a good part of the book takes place inside her thoughts which begin to drift back to her years as a young girl in Ireland. I liked Sister Clodagh and another character that interested me was Mr. Dean, General Rai's English overseer tasked with helping the nuns build the convent. The sisters meet Mr. Dean on the first day of their arrival, a handsome man with an amusing smirk on his face about what the sisters have gotten themselves into. He's been living by himself in this remote region for years, knows the dialect, the people and the customs. Mr. Dean doesn't have any desire to go back to England and one senses, as with Sister Clodagh, that there's a story there, that he's running from something.
I enjoyed Black Narcissus. There is a haunting quality to this book. You feel as you get deeper into the novel that a crisis is coming, you just don't know what form it will take. Rumer Godden does a good job in creating intriguing characters and her descriptions of the beauty of the Himilayas is also well done. I closed Black Narcissus thinking that I would like to investigate what else Rummer Godden has written because she tells a good story..
Great review Kathy! That sounds really good. I had heard of the movie and the author but never read any of her books. I like books that have characters with interesting backstories which the reader gets to explore as the narrative moves forward.
ReplyDeleteAlso congratulations for reading from your own shelves! This is a constant challenge for me too. :D
Thanks Ruthiella, I like that too where you discover a character in a novel, in this case Mr Dean, who could be an interesting subject for a novel all by himself.
DeleteI am really going to make an effort this year to read books from my own shelves. I liked these books enough at one point to order them through my kindle so I am hoping once I start reading I'll find some buried treasures.
This novel has been on my radar for awhile. Stories that build a feeling of coming crises have always appealed to me. The plot and the themes sound fascinating.
ReplyDeleteI believe that there was a film version of this but I have not seen it.
I think that most bookish people have lots of unread books around. Good luck with your project of getting through them!
Thanks Brian, As I understand the film version of Black Narcissus when in came out in the late 1940's was considered a breakthrough in terms of the cinematography,two academy awards. Martin Scorcese was very influenced by it. I think we all have our pile of unread books. Keeping a blog helps because it forces you once you begin a book to stick with it.
DeleteHave to say, I'm not familiar with this book or this author. Although I think I've seen her name before. But you make me want to investigate what else she's read, too. :)
ReplyDeleteThanks Lark, I had never heard of her either although I had heard of the film. I think Rumer Godden is an author worth checking out and she wrote about sixty books during her lifetime so I am curious to take a look at the various plots in her novels to see what else might appeal to me.
DeleteWow. 60 books. That's a lot! I wonder if my library has any of them.
DeleteI have seen quite a few of Rumer Godden's books on Instagram, and I've been wondering about them. Thank you so much for this review. I will definitely get 'Black Narcissus' - it does sound like a great book!
ReplyDeleteThanks Ginette, I hope you like it. She's a good writer and Black Narcissus is one of the books she is most famous for.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDelete